In honor of Edible Manhattan‘s new Alcohol Issue, which features a profile of Compass Box Whisky Company founder John Glaser, Edible Manhattan and Edible Brooklyn recently partnered with the Scotch whisky makers to host the Great King Street Cocktail Competition. Great King Street is a new blend by Compass Box, one named after the Scottish street where the company is registered. Unlike many of Compass Box’s other blends, this one is specifically designed for mixing. So together we asked professional drinks-makers from the two boroughs we cover to create a cocktail made with Great King Street–and at least one seasonally inspired ingredient.
The preliminary round of judging took place last week, and 20 cocktails were made following the recipes provided by contestants at The Rum House by Michael Neff and Kenneth McCoy, co-owners of that lovely refurbished lounge in the Edison Hotel on 47th Street. Contestants had to tote any unique ingredients to the bar, meaning the place was soon cluttered with a tower of plastic tubs filled with homemade syrups, all kinds of locally sourced liqueurs (sour cherry cordial, ginger mead) and rows and rows of bottles of artisanal bitters from cherry vanilla to highland heather. Many made in Brooklyn, natch.
Using a five point scale to rate the drinks across several categories (which included aroma, creativity and “booze factor,” or whether or not you could taste the Great King Street) 20 concoctions were sniffed, sipped, evaluated and narrowed down by representatives from both Compass Box and Edible to a list of five semi-finalist drinks from Manhattan and five semi-finalist drinks from Brooklyn. Those are:
The Artists Commission, from Aaron Cotler of The Crown Inn
The Charlie Hustle, from Abigail Gullo of Fort Defiance
Red Skies at Night, from Max Messier of Whiskey Tango Foxtrot
The Scotch Also Rises, from Richard Murphy of Buttermilk Channel
The Tinderbox, from Anthony Sferra of Buttermilk Channel
The final contest takes place on Monday, January 23, and one winner from the above–dig the Buttermilk Channel internal competition!–will be picked by a panel of three esteemed tasters: Gabrielle Langholtz, the editor in chief of Edible Manhattan and Edible Brooklyn, Patrick Watson, the owner of Stinky Bklyn, Jakewalk, Smith & Wine and the Brooklyn Wine Exchange, and Greg Seider, an owner of the Summit Bar in the East Village and the creator of Le Bernardin’s new cocktail menu. Over the next few days we hope to post the recipes for these five beauties above, too, so stay tuned if you want to test them out at home.